The September 20, 2026 Madrid derby finished Atlético 2–1 Real Madrid, and the Spanish referees' committee subsequently identified one missed red card. Its September 22 review said Lee Kang-in should have been dismissed for his challenge on Federico Valverde. It supported the eventual yellow for Cristian Romero and the penalty and red against Dean Huijsen. Here is how those three rulings fit the published VAR exchanges and the Laws of the Game, and what they can fairly tell supporters about the result.
Updated September 30, 2026. Match result and committee review are historical facts; league positions and future fixtures can change.
What the CTA concluded about the three derby incidents
The clearest answer is narrower than either club's immediate reaction. In its September 22 Tiempo de Revisión programme, the Spanish referees' Technical Committee, known as the CTA, selected three moments from Atlético Madrid's 2–1 home win over Real Madrid. The committee judged that Lee Kang-in should have been sent off for his challenge on Federico Valverde. It accepted the eventual yellow card for Cristian Romero's contact with Jude Bellingham and the penalty plus red card against Dean Huijsen. That is one missed dismissal and two decisions the review supported, not a blanket reversal of the derby.
| Incident | On-field outcome | CTA's later assessment |
|---|---|---|
| Lee on Valverde | Play continued without a red or VAR review | Direct red and VAR intervention were warranted |
| Romero on Bellingham | Booking switched from Bellingham to Romero after review | Romero yellow was appropriate |
| Huijsen on Giuliano Simeone | Penalty and yellow, upgraded to red after review | Penalty and red were appropriate |
Lee Kang-in on Federico Valverde: the missed dismissal
Lee challenged Valverde shortly before half-time and made studs-first contact with his leg as the Madrid midfielder tried to advance. The committee's distinction was not simply that the collision looked painful. Its assessment, reported in detail by AS, focused on contact, the twisting of the joint and a high risk of injury. It called for a direct free kick and red card and regarded the lack of an on-field sanction as a clear and obvious error that the video assistant referee should have corrected. The official RFEF index identifies the derby clip at minute 45. It does not itself supply a written transcript, which is why the detailed description here is attributed to reporting of the review.
Cristian Romero on Jude Bellingham: yellow upheld
This was a different sequence. The referee initially gave the foul and booking against Bellingham. Review showed Romero had stepped on Bellingham after playing the ball, so the caution moved to the Atlético defender. The CTA agreed with that correction, while judging the intensity as reckless rather than sufficiently excessive for a sending-off. Some Madrid supporters wanted a red, and that disagreement is understandable when a boot lands on an opponent's leg. The committee nevertheless backed the eventual yellow. The distinction matters: VAR's intervention to correct who committed the offence does not mean it agreed with Madrid's preferred card colour.
Dean Huijsen on Giuliano Simeone: penalty and red upheld
The third incident favoured Atlético. Huijsen held Giuliano Simeone inside the area as the forward was moving towards goal with the ball under control. The referee gave the penalty and initially showed yellow, then upgraded the card after a VAR review. As El Desmarque's account of the CTA review explains, the committee considered Simeone to have gained position, with a clear path to goal and no realistic opportunity for Huijsen to challenge for the ball. It supported the penalty and dismissal. Readers following the result should therefore keep two things in view at once: Madrid had a valid grievance over Lee, while the committee did not overturn every contentious decision that went against it.
How the VAR interventions unfolded on match night
A retrospective committee review and a live VAR check answer different questions. VAR assists the match referee while play is being officiated; the CTA's programme later assesses selected incidents and explains whether those decisions were correct. The derby is unusually instructive because released audio exists for two checks, while the most serious error identified later was the incident that did not trigger an on-field review. Reading the audio as if it were a transcript of every official thought would overstate what it can show.

Why the Romero review changed the player booked
In the Romero-Bellingham incident, the referee first interpreted the contact in the opposite direction: he penalised and cautioned the Madrid midfielder. The VAR official directed him to the screen because replay appeared to show the Atlético player stepping on Bellingham after the Madrid player had played the ball. As AS's account of the published exchange makes clear, the issue flagged in the call was a confusion about which player had committed the offence. The referee cancelled Bellingham's caution and booked Romero.
That is more precise than saying VAR reviewed Romero for a red and decided against it. The referee could assess the same contact on the monitor and settle on a yellow, and the later CTA review supported that outcome. Supporters can still disagree about the level of force. But the available recording should be described for what it records: an intervention that corrected the foul and booking, followed by an on-field judgement about sanction. It is an example of how the same screen review can repair one mistake without accepting a different complaint.
Why there is no equivalent Lee VAR audio
For the Huijsen incident, the initial penalty survived review. The issue was whether the yellow card sufficiently punished the hold on Giuliano Simeone. The published exchange described the forward's clear route towards goal and the defender's lack of a genuine play for the ball. The referee also considered whether goalkeeper Thibaut Courtois could reach the attack before changing yellow to red. Football España's account of both released exchanges reinforces that these were separate checks with distinct purposes.
Lee's contact with Valverde supplies the uncomfortable contrast. There is no equivalent released on-field-review audio for that challenge because VAR did not call the referee to the monitor, as AS reported. That does not let an outside reader reconstruct every word spoken between officials or establish motive. What can be said is that the later committee review assessed the challenge as one requiring both a red card and intervention. The gap is therefore between the decision made during the match and the committee's later standard, not between two competing versions of a published Lee conversation.
When discussing the derby, it helps to put events in this order: the referee's original call, any VAR recommendation, the final on-field ruling, then the CTA's later assessment. Collapsing those four steps into one angry headline hides the very procedural difference that made this match so contentious. The recorded result remains 2–1; the audio and review explain how particular calls were reached.
The rules behind a red card and a VAR intervention
Cards are not assigned by how dramatic a replay looks or by the eventual medical diagnosis alone. IFAB Law 12, the governing text for fouls and misconduct, distinguishes a careless offence, a reckless challenge deserving a caution, and excessive force or a challenge that endangers an opponent's safety deserving a send-off. The referee evaluates the action itself: point and mode of contact, speed, force, control and danger. An injury may make an incident more visible to viewers, but it is not a substitute for assessing the offence under the law.
Serious foul play versus a reckless challenge
This distinction illuminates Lee and Romero. The CTA assessed Lee's studs contact and the twisting of Valverde's leg as a challenge with a high risk of injury and therefore serious foul play. A direct red follows from that assessment. For Romero, it accepted a yellow after the foul was correctly attributed to him; it treated the force and danger as within the reckless category, even though the contact on Bellingham looked troubling on replay. The ruling is not that stepping on a leg is harmless. It is that the committee drew a different disciplinary line after considering the complete action.
Fans may reach another judgement from the footage. What matters for an accurate account is identifying who made the judgement and on which incident. AS's report of the CTA review explicitly separates the two verdicts. Calling both challenges 'missed reds' would misstate the official review; saying every contact of this type is automatically yellow would be equally misleading. The law asks for a contextual assessment, and the recorded CTA interpretation was different in each case.
Denying an obvious goal-scoring opportunity in the box
Huijsen's sanction rests on a separate part of Law 12: denying an obvious goal-scoring opportunity, usually shortened to DOGSO. The referee must consider the attack's distance from goal, direction, likelihood of controlling the ball, and the location and number of potential defenders. A defender who fouls in the area and concedes a penalty is not automatically sent off in every DOGSO case. When the offender attempts to play or challenge for the ball, the penalty can be accompanied by a yellow. But for holding, pulling or pushing, or where there is no possibility of playing the ball, the law preserves the red card. The CTA judged Huijsen's arm hold on Giuliano Simeone to fit that latter category.
The IFAB VAR protocol also explains why the video team can become involved. Its review categories include penalties, direct red cards and certain mistaken-identity errors when there is a clear and obvious mistake or serious missed incident. The referee, rather than the video assistant, makes the final decision. In the derby, that meant the Huijsen yellow could be upgraded while the penalty stood, and a serious missed red for Lee was eligible for intervention. The rule set provides a useful test for the next controversial clip: first ask what category the decision falls into, then what the referee decided, then what the video evidence actually shows.
What the decisions do and do not say about a 2-1 result
The missing Lee red matters because it happened before the goals. If a player is dismissed around half-time, both coaches must make different decisions about shape, substitutions and risk. Real Madrid supporters are therefore right to regard the error as consequential. Yet no honest analysis can turn a hypothetical red card into a guaranteed Madrid win. The actual match remains Atlético 2, Madrid 1. The Atlético match record lists Alejandro Grimaldo's opener in the 52nd minute, Jonathan David's second in the 59th and Antonio Rüdiger's reply in the 89th. These are recorded events; the alternate sequence never took place.
Another verified red did shape the game that was played. Huijsen was dismissed for the hold on Giuliano Simeone, leaving Madrid with ten players while Atlético retained the penalty. The home side scored from that spot kick and then doubled its advantage. That sequence gave Diego Simeone's team both a lead and a numerical edge, forcing Madrid to chase in circumstances that favour counterattacks and make controlled possession harder. None of this cancels the earlier missed sanction against Lee. It explains why a fan can simultaneously challenge one decision and recognise the effect of a correct decision against their own side.
The performance record also limits any simple 'the referee decided everything' claim. beIN SPORTS' match analysis reports Atlético generated 2.38 expected goals over the match, compared with Madrid's 0.32, and notes Atlético's much stronger second half. Expected goals is a model of chance quality, not a scoreboard and not an adjustment for an alternate eleven-versus-ten scenario. Its value here is more modest: it shows that the match also contained a substantial difference in the opportunities the teams created under the conditions that actually existed.
A useful way to revisit the derby is to keep three ledgers separate. The official result records points earned. The referee review records the committee's assessment of selected decisions. The tactical ledger asks how the sides played, including how the dismissal changed their options. The first can be checked on our results page; its implications for the campaign appear in the table. The second does not itself award points or alter the fixture. The third is a reasoned interpretation, open to debate. Treating them as separate is fairer to both clubs and more useful to supporters than pretending one ledger answers every question.
Why supporters are debating the derby beyond the whistle
The debate after a rivalry match is rarely limited to one frame of video. In a Real Madrid supporters' post-match thread, some commenters focused on the Lee challenge and the referee, while others questioned their team's ball progression, the fit of its forwards and its response after going behind. These are examples of what engaged fans were discussing, not a poll of all Madrid supporters. The distinction is important because the loudest online reaction can reveal a question worth answering without proving a broad consensus.
What a confirmed officiating mistake proves
The CTA finding establishes that, in its judgement, Lee's challenge should have brought a red card and that the video team should have intervened. It gives Madrid's complaint on that specific moment more substance than a purely partisan replay debate. It also raises a reasonable process question: how can a serious-foul-play threshold be applied consistently when the same weekend's review later identifies a challenge the live team missed? Asking that question does not require assuming bad faith by the referee, conspiracy by the league or certainty about the score that would have followed a dismissal.
There is a narrower trust issue too. Fans see VAR screens and hear snippets of official audio for certain interventions, but an unreviewed incident leaves less publicly visible reasoning. The later RFEF programme supplies retrospective scrutiny; it cannot supply the missing live on-field decision. That imbalance in visibility helps explain the frustration. To make the complaint useful, compare decisions against Law 12 and the CTA's own stated assessment rather than collecting only the clips that support one team.
What performance and table context still matters
Madrid's performance is a separate football question. beIN's reported chance figures show Atlético created the stronger opportunities in the match as played. The derby also changed after Huijsen's upheld dismissal, when Mourinho's side had to pursue the game with one fewer player. If the attack struggled to connect before the red, supporters can investigate that too: Was the ball reaching the forwards early enough? Were Atlético's midfielders blocking central progression? Did Madrid create a credible route back after Rüdiger scored late? Those are match-analysis questions, not excuses for a missed call.
The season implications are real but should not be overstated in September. Three points went to Atlético, and the loss affects Madrid's position relative to its rivals on the league table. Yet a single derby does not establish the outcome of a 38-game campaign. The more informative follow-up is whether Madrid improves its chance creation and defensive control in subsequent fixtures, and whether Atlético can repeat its second-half intensity when it does not gain a numerical advantage. Fans can check the upcoming matches rather than freezing both clubs at their derby form.
Where fans can verify the next update
As of September 30, 2026, the most direct public starting point is the RFEF's September 22 review page. It identifies the three Atlético–Real Madrid clips assessed in programme five of the season. Its web page supplies the index and video rather than a detailed English written judgement; the fuller incident-by-incident account in this article is attributed to reports that describe the CTA assessment. A reader who sees a later social-media clip claiming that the committee backed every Madrid complaint should compare it with the Romero and Huijsen conclusions before sharing it.
For the general rule, start with IFAB Law 12 and the VAR protocol. Those documents explain which actions can be red-card offences and which categories VAR may review. They do not by themselves pronounce on this specific tackle; that is the purpose of the match officials' decisions and the CTA review. It is useful to read both levels. Otherwise a rule excerpt about a reckless yellow may be used to excuse a challenge the committee classified as serious foul play, or a passage on penalties may be used to argue incorrectly that Huijsen's dismissal had to be downgraded.
For the match record, the official Atlético page and our La Liga results show the 2–1 finish. The standings show the points context, while the schedule is the place to look for both clubs' next league test. Check the date on any screenshot: a league position, fixture time or player availability can change after this September 30 snapshot. The CTA's finding is a historical assessment of this derby; it should not be mistaken for a live change to the table or a prediction of the next match.
The durable lesson for supporters is a practical one. On a disputed play, establish the final on-field decision; check whether VAR actually intervened; read the relevant law; then compare the later committee view with independent match reporting. In this case that process produces a clear, mixed answer: the Lee red was missed, Romero's yellow survived review, and Huijsen's penalty and red were upheld. It leaves plenty for fans to discuss about officiating consistency and Madrid's performance without inventing an alternate final score.

Comments
Sign in with Google to comment. Keep the conversation useful and football-focused. New comments are reviewed before they appear.
Loading comments…